 |
| Debra Paget cornered by lady convicts |
WHY MUST I DIE? (1960).
Director: Roy Del Ruth.
Lois King (Terry Moore of Postmark for Danger) tries to make a new life for herself after blowing off her boyfriend, Eddie (Lionel Ames), and father, Red (Fred Sherman), both of whom are crooks. She winds up singing at a tony nightclub owned by Kenny Randell (Phil Harvey of The Land Unknown) and the two begin a romance. Unfortunately, just when things are looking up Eddie and his new girlfriend, the hardboiled safecracker Dottie Manson (Debra Paget), re-enter Lois' life. Lois has to give them information that will enable them to rob the nightclub, but a tragedy results from this. Lois and Dottie wind up in the same penal institution where one of them is on death row and the other hides a guilty secret.
 |
| Phil Harvey and Terry Moore |
Why Must I Die?, which also makes a plea against capital punishment, was clearly modeled on I Want to Live, released two years earlier. It's absorbing enough, but low-budget and second-rate, although it was photographed by no less than Ernest Haller. Terry Moore, who also produced the picture, is okay in the lead role but she hardly has the acting chops of Susan Hayward, star of I Want to Live, and overacts quite a bit when she's called upon to get hysterical. That is not the case with Debra Paget, who steals the movie from Moore with her intense and dynamic portrayal of the hard-as-nails Dottie. She's terrific and utterly loathsome.
 |
| Lionel Ames and Debra Paget |
Other cast members in
Why Must I Die? include Robert Shayne (of
The Rebel Set) as another club owner who falls for Lois; Bert Freed as her lawyer, Adler; Sid Melton as an agent; Juli Reding as the sexy Mitzi, who also canoodles with Eddie; and Jackie Joseph (of
Little Shop of Horrors) as another club employee who is having a fling with Kenny, for shame. Eddie's deadly fall off of a fire escape is well-handled as is the ending in the prison, which has a certain amount of minor power. Parts of Dick LaSalle's musical score remind one of
Vertigo.
Verdict: Paget makes her mark! **1/4.
Have only seen Paget in Ten Commandments (which I just rewatched) and opposite Elvis in Love Me Tender. She was gorgeous and a pretty good actor. I guess she didn't do as much as she got older; I don't remember seeing her as anything but an ingenue.
ReplyDelete-Chris
One of countless actors who have a brief moment in the sun but never quite make it to major stardom.
ReplyDelete